Difference between revisions of "Propose Amendment to Article IV Section B"

From ScottishConstitution.Com
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
Line 9: Line 9:
 
::*§ 1. Recall elections of elected officials and civil servants
 
::*§ 1. Recall elections of elected officials and civil servants
  
:::*a. Citizens can request a recall referendum for any public employee or non-elected office-holder in cases of serious neglect of their duties, or direct harm to the functioning of the public services they are responsible for.
+
:::*a. The Citizen Participation and Referenda section of the CSL shall establish the requirements and conditions for holding citizens' recall initiatives.
 
 
:::*b. The Citizen Participation and Referenda section of the CSL shall establish the requirements and conditions for holding citizens' recall initiatives.
 
  
 
::*§ 2. Citizen Constitutional and Legislative initiatives
 
::*§ 2. Citizen Constitutional and Legislative initiatives
  
 
::The CSL shall provide mechanisms for citizens to:
 
::The CSL shall provide mechanisms for citizens to:
:::*a. totally or partially reform this Constitution.
+
:::*a. amend or supplement the CSL in any sphere, except the constitution and social progress.
:::*b. amend or supplement the CSL in any sphere.
+
:::*b. appeal executive decisions
:::*c. determine membership in collective security and defence agencies and/or supranational organizations
 
:::*e. appeal executive decisions
 
  
 
::*§ 3. Conflict resolution referendum
 
::*§ 3. Conflict resolution referendum
Line 26: Line 22:
  
 
:::*b. The Board shall also consider other conflicts to resolve through referendum.
 
:::*b. The Board shall also consider other conflicts to resolve through referendum.
 +
  
 
== Justification for Amendment ==
 
== Justification for Amendment ==
  
 
: Tell us why you would like to make this amendment.
 
: Tell us why you would like to make this amendment.
 
== Observations & Guidelines on Amendments ==
 
 
: 1. Is the article written clearly enough, for the broadest possible comprehension? Can you suggest changes to the text to enhance the clarity and simplicity?
 
 
: 2. Does the Article fit well within the Constitution. What changes could make it fit better?
 
 
: 3. Are there inconsistencies and/or contradictions between the Article and other parts of the Constitution and/or the CSL?
 
 
: 4. Are there changes that could be made to the Article to enhance its functionality?
 
 
: 5. What have we not thought about in this Article which could be implemented?
 

Latest revision as of 22:01, 17 March 2019

Please click the Edit link above, between Read and View History, and make your proposed amendments to the text. If you do not see the Edit link, please login and try again.

Article IV – Electoral integrity and Citizen Referenda

  • Section B: Referenda
A referendum is a binding consultation through popular vote over issues of vital importance, or legal provisions of regional, national or international scope. Initiatives that reduce rights and guarantees shall not be the subject of a referendum proposal. Referenda may serve the following purposes:
  • § 1. Recall elections of elected officials and civil servants
  • a. The Citizen Participation and Referenda section of the CSL shall establish the requirements and conditions for holding citizens' recall initiatives.
  • § 2. Citizen Constitutional and Legislative initiatives
The CSL shall provide mechanisms for citizens to:
  • a. amend or supplement the CSL in any sphere, except the constitution and social progress.
  • b. appeal executive decisions
  • § 3. Conflict resolution referendum
  • a. In matters of great importance to citizens, the President of the Scottish State or the Parliament may call upon the Scottish Electoral Auditor Board to hold a referendum to settle a situation of institutional conflict.
  • b. The Board shall also consider other conflicts to resolve through referendum.


Justification for Amendment

Tell us why you would like to make this amendment.